I really liked how it applied smoothly and evenly to my lashes without any clumping.

I don't think there was anything I was particularly disappointed with - it was quite usable and unremarkable.

To be completely honest, I really liked it. My eyes tend to smudge all mascaras, but the Kiss Me one smudged the most. The best one was the Etude House Bare Skin Cara, but even that one doesn't smudge as much as the Kiss Me. There's no mascara that doesn't smudge at all on my eyes, but for most people it probably won't smudge much. What I was really impressed by was the curl-holding power! I have 8 different mascaras, and this is probably the best one... It applies so naturally and neatly, and I didn't think it would last well, but it really does. That was the most surprising part!!! It applies naturally, but I didn't feel like it gave me much length or volume. I'd recommend this to someone who likes a natural look. I always use black, so I was excited to try a brown shade. Some brown mascaras can look whitish in the sunlight, but this one doesn't. Honestly, I would consider repurchasing this.

Hmm, it just gives a neat application without much expressive volume or length.