What is this? I raved about it as my life essential and wrote 6 reviews, but it's been renewed.. They say the ingredients haven't changed, but the spreadability and moisturizing properties have changed. So I hoarded it this time, but I think I'll have to sell it.

The renewal was incredibly good, but it's a shame that it has changed. I'll have to go find a new toner. ㅠ

Hwahae ▪️Skin type is close to oily and sensitive ▪️Clogged pores and frequent breakouts due to accumulated dead skin cells and abundant sebum ▪️Regularly use chemical exfoliating products (AHA, BHA, LHA, etc.) Hwahae Trial Reviewers ▪️A gentle toner that effectively exfoliates. Although not recommended for cleansing, the reviewer finds it non-irritating for this purpose. ▪️Contains a high concentration of PHA (around 3%), a mild exfoliating ingredient. Suitable for daily use. ▪️Often uses this toner in the morning when even gentle cleansers can leave the skin feeling tight, as it provides adequate clarification without dryness. ▪️Also alternates with a toner without exfoliating ingredients, which the reviewer believes is sufficient on its own. ▪️Purchases an extra bottle when finishing one, keeping a backup ready for immediate repurchase.

Personally, the disappointing points were: ▪️ They don't have significant sales often.. Even when the same line goes on sale, the serum is the main focus of the discount, while the regular sale prices are applied to other products.. Sigh.. There is a large-size version, but the price is not that attractive. It's just a larger size, nothing more. ▪️ The prices keep increasing.. The cream line is also an Esther product, but the price hike for Esther seems relatively higher compared to other products. 😢